Skip to main content
MethodIndustry PlaybooksReal estate & constructionStarter

Screen tenants fairly and legally

A first-pass tenant screening plan for a small landlord: written criteria, the checks you may and may not run, deposits and fees, and how to decline fairly, for England (UK), the US (federal rules), the EU (GDPR, with France as an example), Dubai (UAE) and India, with every other place flagged as not checked.

Use this task 5 quick questions, then open it in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

This is a practical, copy-paste process for you are letting a home yourself, without an agent, and need to choose between applicants. Use it when you want a clear structure, then add your own details.

Verified on 2026-10-2920 sources cited

Quick start

1. Before you advertise, write down what you need from a tenant: enough income, a good reference, ID. Use the same list for everyone.
2. In England and the US it is illegal to choose or refuse someone because of race, religion, sex or disability, or because they have children; in England also because they get benefits. Everywhere, use the same fair list for everyone.
3. In England: state one rent and do not take higher offers. Take no rent before the agreement is signed. Holding deposit up to 1 week's rent, tenancy deposit up to 5 weeks' (6 weeks if the yearly rent is GBP 50,000 or more), at most 1 month's rent in advance after signing. Check the right to rent of every adult. By your region's end date (regions open in turn from 15 December 2026), register yourself and the home on the government's Register your rental property service.
4. In the US: if anything in a credit or screening report plays any part in saying no, asking for a co-signer or charging more, send the applicant an "adverse action" notice.
5. In the EU: ask only for the data you need (in France, only the documents on the official list). In Dubai: register the contract in Ejari. In India: check whether your state uses the Model Tenancy Act (deposit up to 2 months' rent).
6. Write down why you said yes or no.
7. This is a first-pass check, not legal or tax advice. Confirm with a qualified accountant or lawyer for your country.

Before you start

  • You are deciding whether a property is a good investment. Analyse a real estate investment deal
  • You want to evict a tenant, increase rent mid-tenancy or deal with arrears. Get advice from a lawyer or local housing advice service.
  • You are taking over from a letting agent, or need the other checks before a tenancy starts (safety certificates, energy certificate, local licensing, where the current deposit is protected). This method covers choosing a tenant only; check GOV.UK or a housing adviser for the rest.
  • You let social housing, student halls or holiday lets. Different rules apply; this method does not cover them.
  • The property is in a country or US state where you need local landlord law in detail. This method gives federal US rules only.

Full method

How to use this method

  1. 1. Copy or downloadCopy the prompt below, or download the method file and attach it to your chat.
  2. 2. Paste into any AIChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Copilot. Replace each [PLACEHOLDER] with your details, or let the AI ask you.
  3. 3. Add your materialAttach your own files, data or brief so the AI works from your facts, not guesses.

The prompt

Paste it as-is. The AI will ask for anything still in [BRACKETS].

Download .md
# Screen tenants fairly and legally
Method by Deepstory Research: deepstoryresearch.com/method/tenant-screening

You are a lettings compliance specialist who helps private landlords choose tenants fairly and within the law. Follow the method below step by step. Goal: A first-pass tenant screening plan for a small landlord: written criteria, the checks you may and may not run, deposits and fees, and how to decline fairly, for England (UK), the US (federal rules), the EU (GDPR, with France as an example), Dubai (UAE) and India, with every other place flagged as not checked.

## My inputs
- Where the property is: [WHERE_THE_PROPERTY_IS]  (example: Leeds, England)
- Property and rent: [PROPERTY_AND_RENT]  (example: 2-bed house, GBP 1,100 a month)
- Who is letting it: [WHO_IS_LETTING_IT]  (example: me, a private landlord, no agent)
- Checks you plan to run: [CHECKS_YOU_PLAN_TO_RUN]  (example: credit check, previous landlord reference, ID)
- Applicants so far: [APPLICANTS_SO_FAR]  (example: 9 enquiries, 3 want to apply)

Before you start: if any input above is still in [BRACKETS] or missing, ask me for it in one short numbered list and wait. Do not guess. If I attached files (data, briefs, Deepstory evidence files), treat them as the primary source.

## Steps to follow
1. Confirm where the property is (country, and state, emirate or city), the rent, and who is letting it.
2. Write screening criteria before advertising, the same for every applicant: affordability, references, identity and legal checks.
3. List the checks that are required, allowed and not allowed in that place, and the data you may ask for.
4. Set the money rules: holding deposit, tenancy deposit, rent in advance and fees.
5. Plan how to record decisions, decline fairly and send any notices the law requires.
6. Flag every rule not checked and the questions for a lawyer or local authority.

## Deliver the output in this structure
- Places covered and not checked
- Written screening criteria
- Checks: required, allowed, not allowed
- Deposits, rent in advance and fees
- Decision and decline steps
- Questions for a lawyer

## Quality rules
- Apply the same written criteria to every applicant, in order of application.
- Never use a protected characteristic, or a proxy for one, as a criterion.
- Label the result a first-pass check, not legal or tax advice, and name the places covered.
- Label every number as FACT (with source and date), ESTIMATE (show the calculation) or ASSUMPTION.
- If a Deepstory evidence file is attached, use its figures as the reference values and cite its source references; tag claims that are not from it as [UNVERIFIED].
- End with: the 3 assumptions that matter most, what would change the answer, and the single best next step.

What you need to give the AI

InputPlaceholderExample
Where the property is[WHERE_THE_PROPERTY_IS]Leeds, England
Property and rent[PROPERTY_AND_RENT]2-bed house, GBP 1,100 a month
Who is letting it[WHO_IS_LETTING_IT]me, a private landlord, no agent
Checks you plan to run[CHECKS_YOU_PLAN_TO_RUN]credit check, previous landlord reference, ID
Applicants so far[APPLICANTS_SO_FAR]9 enquiries, 3 want to apply

Use it when

  • You are letting a home yourself, without an agent, and need to choose between applicants.
  • You want written screening criteria before advertising.
  • You are about to take a holding deposit, run a credit check or turn an applicant down.

Best with: Any chat AI; give the property location, rent and the checks you plan to run.

What you get

  • Places covered and not checked
  • Written screening criteria
  • Checks: required, allowed, not allowed
  • Deposits, rent in advance and fees
  • Decision and decline steps
  • Questions for a lawyer

The AI will ask you first

Answer these before the AI advises you; each one changes what it recommends.

  1. 1

    Where exactly is the property (country, and state, emirate or city)?

    Screening, deposit and registration rules are local: England differs from Scotland, Dubai from Abu Dhabi, one US state or Indian state from another.

    If unknown: Ask; do not apply any rule until the place is known.

  2. 2

    What is the rent (per month or per year), and is the home furnished or shared?

    Deposit caps and affordability are calculated from the rent.

    If unknown: Use the advertised rent and say so. If no rent is set yet, show each cap as a formula and as an example per 1,000 of monthly rent, labelled as an assumption.

  3. 3

    What are your criteria: minimum income, references, guarantor, pets, number of occupants?

    Criteria must be set before advertising and applied the same way to everyone.

    If unknown: Propose criteria based on affordability and references only, and ask the user to confirm them.

  4. 4

    Which checks do you plan to run, and will you use a screening company or credit report?

    Some checks are required (for example Right to Rent in England), some trigger notices (US credit reports), and some are not allowed.

    If unknown: Plan identity, legal-status where required, affordability and one landlord reference.

  5. 5

    Will you take a holding deposit, a tenancy deposit or rent in advance, and how much?

    These are capped or regulated in several places.

    If unknown: Assume none until the caps for the place are checked.

  6. 6

    How will you advertise the home and handle more applicants than one home?

    In England you must publish an asking rent and cannot take offers above it. Processing complete applications in the order received is a rule of thumb that helps you show you chose fairly.

    If unknown: Advertise one rent and process complete applications in the order received.

  7. 7

    Will you live in the home yourself (a lodger or room let), and has any applicant asked about a pet or an assistance animal?

    Living in changes which rules apply (lodgers in England, owner-occupier exemptions in the US); assistance animals are a reasonable accommodation question under US fair housing law, and tenants in England can ask to keep a pet.

    If unknown: Assume you do not live there and the usual rules apply.

The procedure, step by step

Read this before you run it, so you can check the AI actually followed the method.

  1. 1

    Confirm the place

    Country, and state, emirate or city; rent; furnished or shared; who lets it.

  2. 2

    Write criteria

    Affordability, references, identity and required legal checks, occupancy limit; nothing based on protected characteristics.

  3. 3

    Advertise

    One stated rent (England: asking rent, no bidding); same information to everyone. England: register on the Register your rental property service by your region’s end date, and check GOV.UK for when adverts must show registration numbers.

  4. 4

    Collect applications

    Only the data the criteria need; privacy information given; order of arrival recorded.

  5. 5

    Check

    Identity, right to rent where required, references, affordability, credit report if used.

  6. 6

    Take money correctly

    Holding deposit, tenancy deposit and rent in advance within the caps; deposit protected where required.

  7. 7

    Decide and record

    Offer to the first applicant who meets the criteria; written reasons for declines; legal notices sent; in England, the required tenancy information given to the tenant in writing (for example in a written tenancy agreement).

  8. 8

    Register and store

    Register the tenancy where required (Ejari); keep and then delete applicant data on a set schedule.

Worked example

The figures below are illustrative. Use your own numbers and facts.

Scenario: A private landlord lets a 2-bed house in Leeds, England, at GBP 1,100 a month, without an agent.

Input: Three applicants: A works full time; B receives Universal Credit and has two children; C offers GBP 1,200 a month to secure the house. The landlord plans to take a holding deposit and 2 months’ rent in advance.

Output excerpt: Places covered: England. Not checked: any other place. Criteria (written before advertising): affordability including benefit income, one previous landlord reference, ID, and Right to Rent for every adult. Process complete applications in order of arrival. C: you cannot accept GBP 1,200; the rent is the advertised GBP 1,100. B: you cannot refuse because they receive benefits or have children; assess B on the same criteria as A. Holding deposit: at most 1 week’s rent = 1,100 x 12 / 52 = GBP 253.846, so take no more than GBP 253.84 (round down), one applicant at a time, for up to 15 days unless agreed otherwise in writing. Tenancy deposit: at most 5 weeks’ rent = GBP 1,269.23, protected in an approved scheme within 30 days. Rent in advance: at most 1 month (GBP 1,100), and only after the agreement is signed, so the planned 2 months is not allowed. Right to Rent: check every adult who will live there (if B has a partner aged 18 or over moving in, check them too). At signing you may ask for at most GBP 1,269.23 deposit plus GBP 1,100 rent = GBP 2,369.23, less the GBP 253.84 holding deposit if the tenant agrees to credit it (GBP 2,115.39). Give the required tenancy information in writing. Leeds is in Yorkshire and Humberside, where the registration period runs from 15 April to 14 July 2027: register yourself and the house by 14 July 2027 (you can register earlier); the fee is GBP 65 a year, reduced for registrations during the roll-out. This is a first-pass check, not legal or tax advice. Confirm with a qualified accountant or lawyer for your country.

Check your result

Before you trust the AI's output, confirm each of these.

  • ☐ Places covered and not checked are named at the top.
  • ☐ Criteria are written, apply to everyone and contain no protected characteristic or proxy.
  • ☐ Every deposit or advance is within the cap for the place, with the arithmetic shown, or the output says no cap was found in the sources (Dubai).
  • ☐ Required checks and notices (Right to Rent, adverse action notice, Ejari) are listed where they apply.
  • ☐ The output says it is a first-pass check, not legal or tax advice.
What you'll get(show template)
## Tenant screening plan: [PROPERTY], [DATE]

Places covered: [only those involved among England (UK), US federal rules, EU GDPR, France, Dubai (UAE: tenancy contract and Ejari only), India (Model Tenancy Act where adopted)]. Not checked: [every other place involved, including state or city law, and topics not covered for a listed place, for example Dubai deposits, cheques, discrimination and data rules].

### Written criteria
Criterion | Standard | Evidence asked for

### Checks
Check | Required, allowed or not allowed | Rule | When

### Money
Item | Your plan | Legal limit | Calculation | OK?

### Decision and decline steps
Step | What to do | Record kept

### Questions for a lawyer or local authority
1. [Question]

This is a first-pass check, not legal or tax advice. Confirm with a qualified accountant or lawyer for your country.

Quality checks built into the prompt

  • • Apply the same written criteria to every applicant, in order of application.
  • • Never use a protected characteristic, or a proxy for one, as a criterion.
  • • Label the result a first-pass check, not legal or tax advice, and name the places covered.
  • • Every number labelled FACT, ESTIMATE or ASSUMPTION; claims outside attached evidence tagged [UNVERIFIED].

Decision rules

If/then rules the AI should apply. Heuristic rules are a practitioner's rule of thumb, not a platform rule.

IfThenType
You let a home in England (from 1 May 2026).New tenancies, and existing assured shorthold tenancies, are now assured periodic tenancies with no end date, and you cannot evict using the section 21 "no fault" process; you need a legal ground for possession. Choose carefully, because ending a tenancy is harder.Legal rule
You advertise or agree rent for a home in England.Publish an asking rent. You cannot invite or encourage bidding, and you cannot accept an offer above the advertised rent. You cannot ask for, encourage or accept any rent before the tenancy agreement is signed.Legal rule
You decide who to let to in England.A person letting premises must not discriminate in the terms offered, by refusing to let, or in how people looking for a home are treated, because of race, religion or belief, sex, sexual orientation, disability, pregnancy and maternity, or gender reassignment (age and marriage or civil partnership are not covered for lettings), and must not harass or victimise applicants. Narrow exceptions exist for small premises where you or a relative live and share parts with the occupier, and for an owner-occupier letting privately without an agent or advert; even then, race discrimination is unlawful. Ask a lawyer before relying on an exception.Legal rule
You choose between applicants in England.You cannot discriminate against applicants who receive benefits or who have children. Applicants can ask to keep a pet; you can refuse only with a valid reason.Legal rule
You take a holding deposit in England.Take at most 1 week’s rent, and only one holding deposit at a time. Hold it for up to 15 calendar days unless you agree another period in writing. You may keep it only if the applicant fails a Right to Rent check, withdraws, does not respond, or gives false or misleading information that affects their suitability, and you must give written reasons within 7 days. Otherwise return it within 7 days, or, with the tenant’s agreement, put it towards the first rent or the deposit once they sign.Threshold: 1 week’s rent = monthly rent x 12 / 52, rounded downLegal rule
You take a tenancy deposit or rent in advance in England.The tenancy deposit is capped at 5 weeks’ rent where annual rent is below GBP 50,000, and 6 weeks’ rent where it is GBP 50,000 to GBP 100,000. Rent in advance is limited to 1 month, requested only after signing and before the start date; taking rent before signing is a prohibited payment, with a council fine of up to GBP 5,000 for a first breach. Protect the deposit in a government-approved scheme within 30 days of receiving it and give the tenant the scheme information.Threshold: Deposit 5 weeks’ rent (6 weeks from GBP 50,000 a year); 1 month’s rent in advanceLegal rule
You let a home in England.Before the tenancy starts, check the right to rent of every adult aged 18 or over who will live there, whether or not they are named on the agreement. Check everyone, not only people you think are not British. If someone has time-limited permission, check within the 28 days before the tenancy starts.Legal rule
You let a home in England from 15 December 2026.Register yourself and the property on the government’s "Register your rental property" service (the Private Rented Sector Database). It opens region by region, each with a 3-month period, from 15 December 2026 (West Midlands) to 14 November 2027 (South West); you can register early. During the roll-out you must register properties that are let, or become let, by your region’s end date, and complete the property record within 28 days of registering. In future you will have to register an empty property before advertising it and show registration numbers in adverts; check GOV.UK before you advertise. The fee is GBP 65 a year per property. Failing to register can bring a council penalty of up to GBP 7,000, and while unregistered you cannot get a possession order except on the anti-social behaviour grounds.Threshold: Register by your region’s end date (for example Yorkshire and Humberside: 15 April to 14 July 2027)Legal rule
You let a home in the US.The federal Fair Housing Act bars discrimination in renting because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or disability. HUD has withdrawn several earlier guidance documents and says it will prioritise cases of intentional discrimination, but the Act still applies in full.Legal rule
You set pet, occupancy or other rules, or write an advert, in the US.Refusing reasonable accommodations in rules or policies that a disabled person needs for equal use of the home is discrimination, so treat a request for an assistance animal under a "no pets" rule as an accommodation request. Never publish a notice or advert that shows a preference or limitation based on a protected class; this applies even where the small-owner exemptions (an owner renting a single-family house without an agent and owning no more than three, or a unit in an owner-occupied building of up to four units) apply. The exemptions are not permission to discriminate: a separate federal law (42 U.S.C. 1982) gives everyone the same right to lease property regardless of race, and state law often removes the exemptions; check with a lawyer before relying on them.Legal rule
You use a credit or tenant screening report in the US.You may get a report on someone applying to rent, and you must certify you will use it only for housing. If you deny the application, require a co-signer, or charge a higher deposit or rent based wholly or partly on the report (even if it was not the main reason), give an adverse action notice with the reporting company’s name, address and phone number, a statement that the company did not make the decision, and the applicant’s right to a free report within 60 days and to dispute errors. If you used a credit score, include the score, its source, date and range, and the key factors that lowered it. Securely destroy reports and information taken from them when done.Legal rule
You screen applicants in the EU.Collect only personal data that is adequate, relevant and limited to what you need to choose a tenant (data minimisation), and tell applicants who you are, why you collect each item, who sees it, how long you keep it and their rights. Do not collect criminal record data unless EU or national law authorises it; a private landlord usually has no such basis. In England the same principles apply under the UK GDPR.Legal rule
You let a home in France.There is an official list of documents a landlord may ask from an applicant and from a guarantor; asking for any other document is prohibited. Use the list on service-public.gouv.fr, for example through the DossierFacile service.Legal rule
You let a home in Dubai.Register the tenancy contract in Ejari; registration is mandatory and in the unified tenancy contract the landlord undertakes to register it. Registration attaches the original unified tenancy contract and the applicant’s Emirates ID. Tenancies are governed by Law No. 26 of 2007 as amended by Law No. 33 of 2008, and rent increases by Decree No. 43 of 2013. The cited sources set no fixed cap on the security deposit; record the amount in the unified tenancy contract and say no cap was checked.Legal rule
You let a home in Dubai and choose between applicants.The cited Dubai sources cover the unified tenancy contract, Ejari and the governing laws only. UAE rules on discrimination, applicant data, the security deposit amount and rent paid by cheques were not checked. Use the written criteria anyway, list these topics as not checked, and ask a Dubai lawyer or the Dubai Land Department before relying on any other rule.Heuristic
You let a home in India.The Model Tenancy Act 2021 is a model law for states to adopt. Where a state has adopted it, the agreement must be in writing, the Rent Authority must be told of it within two months, and the security deposit is capped at two months’ rent for residential premises. Check whether your state has adopted it or still uses its own rent law.Legal rule
You set screening criteria.Write them before advertising and apply them to every applicant in the order complete applications arrive. Record the reason for every decline against the criteria.Heuristic
You check affordability.Common rules of thumb: rent of no more than about 30 to 35% of the household’s gross income, or (used by many UK agents) annual income of at least 30 times the monthly rent, which allows rent up to 40% of income. Treat these as guides, consider savings or a guarantor, and never use them to exclude benefit income in England. Where rent is quoted per year (for example in Dubai), divide by 12 first; the 30-times rule is a UK agents’ habit, not a local rule elsewhere.Heuristic
You check references and identity.Contact previous landlords and employers through details you find yourself, not only the numbers the applicant gives, and see original ID. Fake references are a common fraud.Heuristic
You use social media, AI scoring or "tenant score" tools.Do not judge applicants on photos, names, accents, religion, family plans or other protected characteristics, and do not use tools that cannot explain their scores. Use only the written criteria.Heuristic
You consider criminal records, source of income or immigration status in the US.Many states and cities limit these checks or protect more groups than federal law (for example source of income). Check the state and city rules before using them; this method does not.Heuristic
You let a home in India.Many city police forces ask landlords to register tenant details for police verification. Check the local police requirement; this method does not state it.Heuristic
You will live in the home in England and take a lodger.Right to Rent checks still apply to a lodger, and so do the Tenant Fees Act payment limits. The Register your rental property duty covers homes let on assured or regulated tenancies.Legal rule
You will live in the home and take a lodger or let a room.Other rules in this method (deposit protection, registration, some equality exceptions for small shared premises) may apply differently when you share your home. This method does not settle which; check with a housing adviser before relying on it.Heuristic
The property is in a place not covered (Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, other emirates, EU countries other than France, US state law).Say clearly that the local rules were not checked, and confirm with a local lawyer or housing authority.Heuristic

Failure modes

Common mistakes with this method, how to spot them, and how to fix them.

MistakeSymptomFix
Accepting the highest offer.In England, accepting an offer above the advertised rent breaks the law.Advertise one rent and choose on the written criteria.
"No benefits" or "no children" in an advert or criteria.Discrimination claims and fines in England; familial-status claims in the US.Remove them and assess everyone on affordability and references.
Checking Right to Rent only for applicants who seem foreign.Unlawful discrimination and a breach of the Right to Rent rules.Check every adult who will live there, the same way.
Taking more than one holding deposit, or keeping one without written reasons.Deposit must be returned and penalties may apply.One applicant at a time; written reasons within 7 days if kept.
Taking the first month’s rent, or "rent to secure the property", at the offer stage before the agreement is signed.In England this is a prohibited payment; the council can fine up to GBP 5,000 for a first breach.Take only a holding deposit (up to 1 week’s rent) before signing, and at most 1 month’s rent after signing.
Letting an England home and not registering it on the Register your rental property service by your region’s end date.Council penalty of up to GBP 7,000; possession refused except on anti-social behaviour grounds.Look up your region’s dates on GOV.UK, register yourself and the property (you can do it early) and complete the record within 28 days.
Refusing a US applicant’s assistance animal because of a "no pets" rule.Fair Housing Act disability discrimination claim.Treat it as a reasonable accommodation request and decide it on the facts.
Running criminal record checks on EU applicants.Breach of GDPR Article 10 unless a law allows it.Do not collect criminal records in the EU unless a lawyer confirms a legal basis.
Asking for several months’ rent in advance, including from applicants new to the country or with no credit history.Not allowed in England (1 month maximum, after signing).Use a guarantor or the written affordability criteria instead of extra rent in advance.
Not protecting the deposit.In England a court may refuse a possession order later.Protect it within 30 days and give the tenant the required information.
Denying a US applicant because of a credit report without a notice.Breach of the Fair Credit Reporting Act.Send the adverse action notice with the required details.
Collecting more documents than needed (bank statements, family details).Breach of data minimisation in the EU; in France, asking for documents not on the official list.Ask only for what the criteria need, or the official list in France.
Not registering a Dubai tenancy in Ejari.The tenancy is not recorded with the Dubai Land Department, although registration is mandatory.Register in Ejari as the unified contract requires.
Treating this check as legal advice.Decisions based on a misread or out-of-date rule.Confirm with a qualified lawyer or local housing authority.

Agent mode: if an AI agent runs this unattended

May do without asking

  • • Draft written criteria, an application form that asks only for needed data, and decline letters.
  • • Calculate deposit and rent-in-advance limits from the rent.
  • • Draft the advert text with a single stated rent.

Must stop before (the user decides and does these)

  • • Publishing or changing an advert on a listing site.
  • • Requesting, paying for or uploading applicant data to a credit or screening service.
  • • Taking, keeping or returning any deposit or payment, or changing billing details.
  • • Sending offers, declines or adverse action notices to applicants.
  • • Accepting terms with a screening company, listing site or registration service.
  • • Registering or cancelling a tenancy (for example in Ejari), or registering on the PRS Database.
  • • Contacting referees or employers, or running a government online check (for example a right to rent share code), with an applicant’s details.

Evidence for this method

This method runs on your own material: your files, brief or code. If your task needs market or economic numbers, attach a sourced context file from the evidence library alongside the prompt.

Browse evidence

Run next

Methods that chain well after this one.

Deepstory methods are process guidance for AI tools. Review AI output before relying on it; legal, tax, medical and investment decisions need a qualified professional.