Skip to main content
EvidenceFinanceVisualization detail

Currency in circulation as a share of GDP.

Cash did not disappear

Takeaway: Cash did not disappear. It remains a 0%-cost substitute at the high-ticket end.

Cash persistence

Currency in circulation as a share of GDP, %.

Takeaway: Cash did not disappear. It remains a 0%-cost substitute at the high-ticket end.

Cash persistence

Cash did not disappear. It remains a 0%-cost substitute at the high-ticket end.

Rendering the interactive chart…

Expand data table
Download CSV

Cash did not disappear: full data table

SOURCENine years after demonetisation: currency in circulation to GDP, 2016 / FY2021 / 2025
VALUE BASISActual
LAST VERIFIEDSep 10, 2026

Caveat: The ratio fell partly because nominal GDP grew; currency with the public more than doubled in absolute terms.

How this is calculated

Data table

Download CSV
Cash did not disappear: cash_gdp data table (UPI vs Visa & Mastercard: India’s Payments Rewiring)
PctPeriodSeriesSourceValue basis
12.1Mar 2016cash_gdpNine years after demonetisation: currency in circulation to GDP, 2016 / FY2021 / 2025Actual
14.5FY2021cash_gdpNine years after demonetisation: currency in circulation to GDP, 2016 / FY2021 / 2025Actual
11.112025cash_gdpNine years after demonetisation: currency in circulation to GDP, 2016 / FY2021 / 2025Actual

Method

How this evidence was built

What it measures

This index answers one question: what changes if India starts charging a merchant discount rate (mdr) on upi. Every chart is chosen to isolate one input to that answer: how big the rail is, who it displaced, what the alternative rails cost, where the fee would land, and who pays for the rail today.

How it is calculated

  1. Units. Indian official statistics are published in crore (10^7) and lakh crore (10^12) and are kept in those units rather than converted at a floating INR/USD rate, which would produce a derived number with no citable basis.

Key context

  • The one exception is the network-scale chart, where crore is expressed in billions, a fixed decimal conversion, not an FX conversion.
  • Cross-currency value comparisons are made in prose only.
  • Upi annual series. FY2016-17 and FY2025-26 are from the pib decade release; FY2021-22 to FY2025-26 are from the Ministry of Finance Lok Sabha written reply of 20 July 2026.
  • FY2017-18 to FY2020-21 are not in either government tabulation and are carried from a secondary academic restatement of the same npci monthly series.
  • Those four points are the weakest on the page and are marked as such here rather than presented as equivalent to the parliamentary figures.
  • Compiled and verified 2026-08-11.

Key numbers

  • Upi grew from 2 crore transactions in FY2016-17 to 24,161.69 crore in FY2025-26: ~12,000x on volume but only ~4,000x on value, so average ticket size collapsed (pib-upi-decade / lok-sabha-upi-fy).
  • Debit card transactions fell from 4,953mn (CY2019) to 1,738mn (CY2024); credit cards roughly doubled. Upi substituted for debit, not credit (rbi-psr-cards).
  • Upi 241.6bn transactions (FY2025-26) against Visa 257.5bn (fiscal 2025), but Visa moved $14tn of payments volume (visa-fy25).
  • US merchants paid $198.25bn to accept cards in 2025 at an average 2.36%; Indian merchants pay 0.00% on upi (nilson-2025 / pib-incentive-scheme).

Caveats

Caveat: Volume vs value. Upi volume grew ~12,000x and value ~4,000x over the decade. Any comparison of upi against Visa or Mastercard must state which of the two it is using. Upi leads on transaction count and trails badly on value: upi is 85% of India’s digital payment volume but about 9% of its value. Headlines that call upi "bigger than Visa" are true on count and false on value.

Caveat: Instrument shift. The CY2019 vs CY2024 comparison mixes an rbi card series with an rbi/ibef upi series. Both are rbi Payment Systems Report derivatives on the same calendar-year basis, so the comparison holds, but they are not a single published table.

Caveat: US fee series. The Nilson merchant-fee series has a gap between 2014 and 2022; the intervening annual figures are not in the cited releases and are omitted rather than interpolated. Read the chart as dated observations, not a continuous curve. The fee figure is total merchant processing cost (interchange + network + acquirer), which is a larger number than interchange alone.

Do not use this to

  • What rate, if any, will actually be notified, the bill creates a framework, not a rate.
  • How "small merchant" will be defined; no turnover threshold has been published, and it determines the entire incidence.
  • Current Indian card mdr ranges, not charted, no single authoritative published range was found.
  • Cost of cash to Indian merchants, the missing denominator in any honest acceptance-cost comparison.

Scope

August 2026

Sources

Last verified 10 Sept 2026

How relevant was this information?