Filed rate change against what households paid.
Approved rate increases versus what households actually paid
Takeaway: Coverage quoting only the filed rate systematically understates the household experience.
Approved vs realised
Annual % increase in US home insurance: filed/approved rate change against realised written premium.
Takeaway: Coverage quoting only the filed rate systematically understates the household experience.
Approved vs realised
Coverage quoting only the filed rate systematically understates the household experience.
Rendering the interactive chart…
Expand data table
Unknown values are hatched and never treated as zero. Zero remains a verified value.
Data table
Download CSVHow this evidence was built
What it measures
This index deliberately shows two measures side by side because they are routinely conflated:
How it is calculated
- The gap is the finding. In 2021 approved rates rose 2.8% while realised premium rose 7.6%.
- Context: cumulative 2020–2025 increases reached 46.8%, roughly twice general inflation, about $21bn in aggregate additional household cost.
Key context
- • filed / approved rate change (blue), the rate change insurers are permitted to charge, from regulatory filings.
- Forward-looking.
- Source: Insurify.
- Complete 2021–2025 run, single provider.
- • realised written premium (red): what households actually paid, computed on the naic basis as premiums divided by exposure in house years (one house year = 365 days of coverage on one dwelling), ho-3 policy form.
- Backward-looking and realised.
- Regulators did not approve that difference: it came from rebuilding-cost inflation raising insured values, so the same policy on the same house cost more without any rate increase.
- Reporting that quotes only the filed rate systematically understates what homeowners experience.
- Never mix a filed-rate value and a realised-premium value inside one series.
- Every point’s basis label states which basis it is on.
- This is the household-level consequence of the catastrophe-losses index.
Key numbers
- 2021: 2.8% approved rate increase versus 7.6% realised premium growth (naic-ho-2021).
- Average premium rose from $2,656 (2021) to $3,303 (2024), +24% (iii-facts).
- Cumulative 2020–2025 rate rises of 46.8%, roughly twice general inflation, about $21bn in aggregate additional household cost (cfa-24pct).
Caveats
Caveat: only 2021 was retrieved on the naic realised basis, so the red series is a single bar by design. The other years are omitted rather than back-filled. A related irc figure of 6.97% for 2021 uses the same house-year basis but a wider policy scope (dwelling fire plus homeowners owner-occupied), so it is not interchangeable with the 7.6% ho-3 figure.
Do not use this to
- State-level or peril-specific pricing.
- Availability and non-renewal, which is the other half of the affordability story.
- Insurer profitability.
Scope
2025
Sources
Last verified 10 Sept 2026